Posted by
Waski_the_Squirrel on Wednesday, January 23, 2008 11:21:10 PM
California, the land of fruits and nuts, has done it again! We may very well soon see boys in the girls' locker rooms. This began with a law that attempted to do something good.
Schools should make the effort to prevent bullying. It will happen, but the school should not endorse it or ignore it. When a teacher sees a kid getting picked on, it is the teacher's job to put a stop to it. Some kids bring it on themselves. Others just seem to be chosen for bullying due to size or personality. It is wrong to allow it. While kids do need to learn to toughen up, they also need to learn that society finds bullying behavior to be wrong.
A homosexual student is likely to be bullied. One who is confused about gender is even more likely to be bullied. My own opinion (especially in the latter case) is that there are mental issues that need to be dealt with. However, enough elements of our society have decided that gender confusion is not a mental disorder.
Kids with this kind of confusion should not be bullied. Of course, they will bring it on just by their appearance. Since the school can't forbid these children to dress or behave in this way, the school is left with a bullying problem. It can't allow it, but it will happen. Further, since the student in question believes himself to be of the other gender, he feels he doesn't belong in male locker rooms or male restrooms. Must the school now allow them to use facilities that fit their perceived gender?
Below I cited a Townhall article that believes the bill requires just that. However, it is nevertheless a bad bill. Schools need to put a stop to bullying, plain and simple. Schools should not be in the business of promoting acceptance of any kind. This bill mandates that homosexuality, gender confusion, and other such disorders be treated in a positive light. It specifically mentions discrimination based on these things. The trouble is, that this is difficult to judge and opens up schools for lots of lawsuits.
Is the small, slightly effeminate boy bullied because the kids think he's homosexual? Is it better if they bullied him for being small rather than because they thought he was gay? Can a student get revenge on his bullies by claiming to be gay and making it a discrimination issue?
Schools should stop bullying, pure and simple. Spelling out special classes of bullying and crimes based on gender, race, religion, sexual orientation, and gender confusion just creates jobs for lawyers and causes schools to over react to protect themselves from the possibility of lawsuits.
It was called Senate Bill 777. This is only one ugly facet of the bill (now law). It is specifically aimed at mandating normalization of the homosexual lifestyle. For a few references:
Townhall.comThe text of the billAn alert from the Traditional Values CoalitionProud Parenting believes that this is all a conservative overreactionSacramento Bee